Nina, seriously.
I love my car. It's reliable and we've been through a number of scrapes (y'all have read some of my auto horror stories, most of them my fault) and get out pretty well.
Well now that Nina is all paid off, she is acting up.
I was driving home from yoga class when I turned a corner and BOOM! The car rocks and suddenly I'm riding a little low on my side, the rear tire making a funny noise. I get home and park, and find a big, jagged hole in my rear driver tire that looked like a velociraptor tore into the tire.
AAA put on the spare for free, but I had to pay Sears $220 for a new tire and an alignment.
Not four days later, I noticed a crack in my windshield way down low, so much so that I didn't even see it until I was dusting off the top of the dashboard. It's longer than a dollar bill, so the whole windshield has to be replaced.
I eliminated comprehensive coverage from my auto insurance to save money on the premiums, so there is no free glass repair. I have to pay out of pocket to get a new windshield. Thankfully, I did sign on with AAA, and can get a decent discount using one of their glass partners.
But that's still $194 (about $60 cheaper than the other two companies I called for quotes).
Then Nina started shaking. A silent rumble, but you could feel the vibration in your chest and it made my hands dance on the steering wheel. The Service Engine light came on, then went off. Came on again, went off again and the rumble disappeared. Then they both returned with a vengeance when I came back from Hawaii. I take Nina to get checked out. They told me to go to a dealer to get the definitive diagnosis, but it's either the spark plugs, an inexpensive repair, or something wrong with parts of the engined, which could cost upwards of $1,000 to repair.
The check engine light has gone off and the rumble disappeared... for now.
Cutting my insurance premium in half for the past year will pay for the tire and the windshield, but that still leaves the engine. And all of this will still set back my six-months-of-living-expenses goal... hopefully by no more than a month, but still.
At what point do you stop putting money into a car?
I was hoping to keep Nina running for at least another five years with routine maintenance and simple repairs (like brake pad replacement, new tires, etc.). A whole new engine? Is it even worth doing that with today's cars or should you just get another one? As much as I DO NOT want the hassle of getting another car (and making a car payment for years AND paying higher insurance, lord no, help me), I also don't want to pour what could amount to a new(er) car into this one. Come on Nina, you're only five, work with me!
How do you guys decide when it's time for a new (as in new to you, it could be used) vehicle?